ASSESSMENT

Product Assessment

Inspect the product's current state independently from the engineering perspective and the business perspective. Quality-attribute taxonomy follows ISO 25010; tension detection between attributes borrows from ATAM's trade-off analysis.

Quality-attribute taxonomy
ISO 25010
Trade-off analysis
ATAM
Presets
Export

Summary is for GOVERNANCE.md. Keep the full report at docs/assessment-YYYY-MM-DD.md.

01Business PerspectiveBIZ

5
Indirect efficiency gainProduct quality directly drives revenue
5
Internal users onlyEnd customers use it directly
5
Ample development timeFast market entry is critical
5
Simple repetitive workSpecialized knowledge / complex business rules
5
Single teamMulti-team, multi-role collaboration
5
Simple classification / filteringStrategic judgment / financial / customer-facing commitments
5
Blue ocean / earlyRed ocean / validated market
5
Niche / smallLarge-scale / mass market

02Engineering PerspectiveDEV

5
Internal-tool gradeFinancial/medical-grade security required
5
Intermittent errors toleratedFailure halts the business
5
Internal policy onlyExternal audit / legal obligation
5
Manual testingAutomated evaluation pipeline required
5
Async / batch acceptableReal-time response required
5
Minimal data, simple executionLarge-scale data analysis / learning is core
5
Small-scale operationLarge-scale concurrent processing
5
Loose cost constraintsOperating cost / ROI sensitive
5
AI as assistant, humans decide everythingAI decides autonomously; humans handle exceptions

Integrated diagnosis

Governance Demand44

Mid-level. Apply governance to core areas first and expand gradually.

Implementation Difficulty37

Relatively simple implementation. You can start fast with an MVP.

Business Complexity46

Mid-level business complexity. Focus on core-stakeholder alignment.

MVP Feasibility52

Constrained but MVP is releasable if scope is narrowed. Select only mandatory requirements.

Launch Risk26

Low risk. There is ample slack or the requirements are light.

Operational Burden44

Mid-level operational burden. Build the core-metric dashboard first.

Profile by perspective

Business Perspective

RevenueCXTTMDomainStakeholdersDecisionMaturitySize

Engineering Perspective

SecurityReliabilityComplianceTestingLatencyDataScaleCostAutonomy